Winton Forum

 

Planning Issues

Accredited Landlord Scheme

7 Feb 2013

Trusted and reputable landlords from across Dorset will soon be able to sign up to a new Dorset Register of Accredited Landlords.

Working with a number of national landlord organisations, Bournemouth Council is the first local authority in England to launch the regional scheme which will encourage landlords to become accredited with an approved organisation and then be included on the Dorset Register, made available for local residents to view.

To become registered, landlords will have to meet certain requirements including signing up to a code of conduct as well as taking part in regular professional development and in turn will benefit from being publicised on the register. Other benefits will vary from Council to Council, in Bournemouth they will include discounted HMO (Houses in Multiple Occupation) licence fees, access to grants for free insulation and priority with a new housing benefit system. Poole, Christchurch, East Dorset and Purbeck Councils have also signed up to the scheme and a register of accredited landlords for the area will be listed on each of the local authority's websites.

Councillor Robert Lawton, Cabinet Member for Housing, said: "We're committed to raising the standard of accommodation in the private rented sector and the new Dorset Register aims to work with local landlords to encourage as many as possible to sign up to the scheme. Working closely with the accreditation bodies we can ensure that landlords are fully aware of their legal requirements and ensure that properties are well managed. This will free up more time for the Council to focus its efforts on tackling problem properties."

Bournemouth is working with the National Landlords Association, Residential Landlords Association Accreditation Scheme and the National Landlord Accreditation Scheme. Once a landlord is accredited with one of the three accredited bodies they can apply to be included on the Dorset register.

A statement on behalf of the three accreditation bodies working with the Council, said: "We are extremely pleased to join Bournemouth Council in establishing this new Dorset-wide landlord register to help promote improvements to the private rented sector. The register will make it very easy for local residents to view a list of trusted and professional landlords who provide good quality and well managed accommodation in Dorset."

More information can be found at: www.bournemouth.gov.uk/accreditedlandlords


Housing issues in the Winton and Charminster Area

Bournemouth Borough council has issued the following release today 19 November:

Targeted enforcement, landlord accreditation and more partnership working is being considered to improve housing conditions and the standards of management of Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs) in Bournemouth.

The Council has been investigating a range of options to tackle a variety of issues raised by residents in the Winton and Charminster area about the poor conditions of HMOs as well as other community-related issues such as noise, unsightly gardens, anti-social behaviour and letting boards.

Councillors will be considering at Cabinet (20 November) an approach which combines the robust use of enforcement powers with improved partnership working and a wider Landlord Accreditation Scheme to improve HMOs in the Winton East, Wallisdown and Winton West and Queens Park wards. This could mean that a designated officer would be assigned to the Winton wards to carry out targeted enforcement, engage with landlords, partners and the community to improve housing conditions and deal with residents' concerns about the area.

The suggestion follows public consultation which found that many people felt that tougher action should be taken against landlords who do not maintain or properly manage their properties. The problems of noise nuisance, anti-social behaviour, parking and rubbish bins were also highlighted.

Councillor Robert Lawton, Cabinet Member for Housing, said: "We are committed to tackling the problems that residents have highlighted in their wards. It was very clear from feedback through the public consultation that local residents, partners and landlords wanted tougher action to be taken to tackle these issues. After investigating a range of options, including Additional Licensing for HMOs, the Council is now considering a combination of the options, including targeted enforcement action, a stronger landlord accreditation scheme and closer working with the police, university and the community to bring about the improvements called for."

Richard Lambert, CEO of the National Landlords Association, said: "The NLA welcomes Bournemouth Council's proposals to work collaboratively with landlords, letting agents and the local community in order to improve standards.

"It is essential that Bournemouth Borough Council uses its existing powers to enforce standards wherever necessary, and does not hesitate to prosecute the criminals who exploit people in need of housing. Equally, landlords must show their professionalism by continuing to strive for high standards through landlord accreditation and continued professional development.

Bournemouth University and Arts University College joint statement:"Bournemouth University (BU) and the Arts University College at Bournemouth (AUCB) make a substantial economic and social contribution to the local area and many of our students are involved in voluntary and community work.

"However, we recognise that anti-social behaviour from a small minority of our students can impact substantially on the community. Over the past few years BU and AUCB have been working very closely with the council and police to try to tackle this and we already fund dedicated police officers and out of hours Environmental Health Office support.

"BU and AUCB recognise that there is more to be done and therefore we remain committed to our partnership work with local community services, wholeheartedly support this initiative and will continue to contribute to the funding of community initiatives."

NOTES:

The dedicated officer for Winton would be part funded (£15,000) by Bournemouth University

Public consultation took place between 2 July and 7 October 2012.

There are 1,020 known HMOs in the three Winton wards.

A House in Multiple Occupation, (HMO) is a property which is occupied by three or more people forming two or more households, where facilities such as kitchens and bathrooms are normally shared. It may include bedsits, shared houses and some converted buildings containing flats.


HMO Consultation: July - October 2012

Local residents, groups, businesses and landlords are being asked to have their say on a proposed scheme to improve housing conditions and the standards of management of Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMOs) in Bournemouth.

The Council is considering the options available to help improve the living conditions for tenants living in HMOs in Winton East, Wallisdown and Queen's Park. These areas have been identified as having a large number of HMOs where more work needs to be done to improve housing conditions and help deal with noisy neighbours.

Currently, Bournemouth operates a mandatory licensing scheme for larger HMOs (homes that are three or more storeys and occupied by five or more people forming two or more separate households). It is now considering the introduction of an 'Additional Licensing' scheme as one of the options for the area. This will mean that all other HMOs in the three wards identified will have to be licensed.

Consultation will start next week and the public are urged to share their views and give feedback on the proposed options.

The benefits of an Additional Licensing scheme include:

* Any landlord operating an HMO in the area would have to apply for a licence to operate, enabling the Council to ensure standards are maintained

* It will improve the standard of HMOs in the area, including health and safety of the occupants, provision of amenities and external appearance of the property

* It enables the Council to specify the maximum number of persons who can occupy a property

* The Council can attach conditions relating to the management, including requiring the landlord to take steps to prevent or reduce anti-social behaviour of occupiers and people visiting the property

* Provides contact details for all HMO landlords that will enable a better working relationship between the Council and landlords in dealing with, and resolving issues.

Public consultation has been extended to take place from Monday 2 July until Sunday, 7 October 2012.

More information and a questionnaire can be found at: www.bournemouth.gov.uk/wintonhmoconsultation .

A hard copy of the questionnaire is also available from all Bournemouth libraries or Council reception points, or call 01202 451430 to request a copy.


Notes from Council Leader John Beesley on Houses in Multiple Occupation - HMOs

  • HMOs make an important contribution in the provision of affordable accommodation in the community, especially for single person households. This provision will become particularly necessary following the changes to the local housing allowance.

  • Bournemouth has always been pro-active in ensuring standards are maintained in HMOs with comprehensive inspection programmes in place. Bournemouth was the first Council in the country to develop a registration scheme for HMOs.

  • A Landlord Accreditation Scheme was first introduced in Bournemouth in 2004. The scheme is a form of self-regulation that acknowledges good landlords. It is a successful way to help improve and maintain standards in the private rented sector.

  • Certain types of HMO are required to be licensed with the Council under a national, mandatory scheme. These are the larger multi-occupied properties which are three storeys or more and are occupied by 5 or more residents who form two or more households. There are currently around 500 licensed HMOs in the borough.

  • Following detailed consultation with landlords, community groups and other stakeholders, fully revised HMO Amenity Standards were introduced in April 2010.

  • The majority of the HMOs known to the Council are concentrated in the Boscombe and Winton areas. The issues associated with them tend to differ between the areas.

  • The Council works in partnership with the Police, the university, residents groups and ward councillors to minimise the impact of the high density of HMOs in the Winton area.

Article 4 Direction (Planning Controls for HMOs)

  • An 'Article 4 Direction' is a planning tool, used in conjunction with policies set out in the Local Development Framework Core Strategy that can be used to remove permitted development rights from a particular development.

  • An Article 4 Direction was introduced in Bournemouth in December 2011 which removed the permitted development rights for a change of use of a dwelling house within use class C3 to an HMO within use class C4 (one which is occupied with 3-6 occupants sharing facilities)

  • This means that any new HMO containing between 3 - 6 occupants will now require planning permission. It will not have any impact on existing HMOs but will enable the council to limit the number of new HMOs where there is already a high saturation in the locality.

The Oxford Initiative (Additional Licensing of HMOs)

  • Councils can designate areas for additional licensing in respect of some or all of the HMOs that are not already subject to mandatory licensing. In 2010 the requirement for government approval for a scheme changed to local councils making the decision.

  • Before designating an area for licensing, extensive research and consultation needs to be carried out. There must be a sound business case and the Council must be able to show a significant proportion of the HMOs in the area are giving rise to problems due to their poor management.

  • Problems may include poor external condition, poor internal conditions impacting on the occupiers, problems of anti social behaviour and landlords not taking reasonable and lawful steps to deal with issues.

  • HMOs are a major concern in Oxford and the city council has introduced a city wide additional licensing scheme to tackle the poor conditions there. The council had used all their existing powers to their full extent and concluded that they needed to do more to improve the quality and standard of management of their HMOs.

  • Bournemouth is now giving consideration to how a similar scheme could be developed for Bournemouth, including the areas it may apply to and the timescales for introduction.

  • The Council will carry out full consultation with stakeholders, community groups, landlords and Bournemouth residents before any scheme is introduced.

Student Housing in Oxford under HMO laws

Background

Oxford has decided to use the Additional Licensing provision in the 2004 Act to make all its HMOs licensable. This is in order to control the spread of HMO’s and to regulate their use and standards.
According to the Oxford City Council Website:

They form an unusually high percentage of houses in the city with 1 in 5 of the resident population living in an HMO. The House Condition Survey 2005 reported that HMOs provided the poorest homes in the city and that 70 per cent were unsafe.

HMOs generate over 2000 service requests/complaints a year to Oxford City Council and the number of complaints have risen steadily over recent years, despite surveys indicating many problems go unreported. They are also associated with issues that affect the neighborhood such as rubbish.

Many three storey HMOs are already licensed under the existing licensing rules. However, Councillor Joe McManners, Executive Member for Housing said:

Local residents in Oxford have told us that the Council needs to do more to control the impact of HMOs and we’ve listened to what they’ve had to say. We’ve tried using all our existing powers but they haven’t been enough to make the difference that is needed. We believe that additional licensing will provide us with those extra powers that we need and that it will have a really positive impact. Our aim is to improve the living conditions for tenants within HMOs as they provide the worst accommodation in the City.

In 2005, Oxford City Council undertook a housing condition survey that claimed that 70 per cent of HMOs were 'unsafe', 61.3 per cent had below standard fire detection and 16.9 per cent had no fire detection at all.

It is hope that the HMO licensing will help to regulate unsafe housing and end the exploitation of students by landlords who provide it. It is hope that this new legislations will encourage universities to provide more purpose-built accommodation, as it is a more efficient use of land and leads to reduced tension between different types of housing and different types of residents.

The consultation ended in March 2011 and it will now take until 2012 to be implemented as the council is giving a year's notice of the change. Until then there is no evidence of the schemes success or failure.

The cost of HMO licensing

At about £591,931 per year, the scheme will be quite expensive, although the Council state that it will be covered by the licensing fees. However others are not so sure. Jan Bartlett, owner of Cowley Road firm Premier Letting, speaking in the Oxford Mail said that the cost could be prohibitive if landlords don’t pay the license fees:

“The scheme will be difficult to police and bad landlords just won’t sign up”

She suggested that the Local Authority save money by using local letting agents to police the scheme instead of hiring new staff. Although presumably she is not suggesting that agents perform this public service for nothing.

Legal Action

PainSmith Solicitors along with Jonathan Manning and Justin Bates of Arden Chambers were been instructed by a group of Oxford landlords, lettings agents, and other interested parties to pursue an action for judicial review of Oxford City Council’s decision to make an additional licensing designation for the whole of Oxford.

PainSmith asserted that the scheme, if carried forward as currently planned, would leave many landlords with their properties designated as HMOs but because Oxford intends to “phase” licence applications over the next 3-4 years these landlords would not be able to apply for a licence. This would, as a consequence, place these landlords in breach of the law and further make them unable to serve a valid notice under section 21 of the Housing Act 1988 on their tenants. This situation cannot be what the Council intends and is simply irrational.

Further Information

http://www.oxford.gov.uk/PageRender/decH/Houses_in_Multiple_Occupation_occw.htm
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/property/article-2031337/Will-students-driven-house-shares-Oxford-leads-clampdown-fee-rise-landlords.html#ixzz1fBaFlcOA
http://www.landlordlawblog.co.uk/2010/08/03/oxford-leads-the-way-with-hmo-licensing/


To Let boards

17 March 2011

The Town Hall has come up with the following information following a request from Anson Westbrook.

Subsection (2) of Class 3A of the Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements)(England) Regulations 2007 states "No advertisement may be displayed indicating that land or premises have been sold or let, other than by the addition to an existing board of a statement that a sale or letting has been agreed, or that land or premises have been sold, subject to contract"

Subsection (3) of Class 3A states "The advertisement shall be removed within 14 days after completion of a sale or a grant of tenancy"

Consequently once an agreement has been made that a person or group of persons can occupy a property a slip can be added to an existing 'To Let' board to say 'Let , subject to contract or STC', once the letting of a tenancy has been completed the board has to be removed within 14 days. It is not unusual for agreements to be made for a property to be let months in advance of the tenancy being granted and therefore boards stating 'Let, subject to contract' can be displyed legally during this period. It is then a matter for the relevant agent to ensure that their boards are removed within a period of 14 days from the grant of the tenancy.

In the cases of boards that simply state 'Let' we assume a tenancy has been granted and in these circumstances the board should be removed within 14 days of the 'Let' sign appearing however, we are finding an increasing number of situations where a 'Let' board is displayed but the tenancy has yet to be granted. We are in the process of drafting a letting to all letting agents reminding of the requirement to add the words 'subject to contract' or the abreviation 'STC' to their boards where tenancies have yet to be granted and also that their boards should be removed within 14 days of the date the tenancy is granted.


Council leader takes up HMO issue

1.October 2010

Following lobbying from the Winton Forum, new Council Leader Peter Charon has written to the housing minister.

Here is his letter:

Dear Mr. Shapps,

Houses in Multiple Occupation – Bournemouth Borough Council

I am writing to you in my capacity as both the Leader of the Council and the Housing Portfolio Holder.

Bournemouth has a fantastic University – which has grown dramatically over the past 15 or so years. We also have one of the largest concentrations of Language Schools in the country. That growth however has meant an ever increasing influx of young people but the pace of purpose built student halls of residences has not been able to keep up.
As a consequence the gap has been filled by private sector landlords with significant numbers of students living in several of our communities, notably Winton, Wallisdown, Charminster, Boscombe and of course our Town Centre. Inevitably these properties are Houses in Multiple Occupation – HMO’s. In general these properties are well managed and run, but there are some that are not. Moreover, many residents in those particular parts of our town face the usual issues associated with student HMO’s particularly but not limited to absentee management, noise, refuse/recycling, parking, letting agents boards and so on. It is essential that the Council responds to and addresses those concerns as a matter of urgency.

We were certainly supportive of the new planning regulations that came into force on April 1 2010 – as this would have been the key way in which we would have been able to control the spread and concentrated proliferation of student house / HMO’s. Like a number of other Councils – Milton Keynes and Leeds amongst them - I too feel the need to write to you and express disappointment at the relative lack of due consideration and consultation in respect of your decision to abolish the requirement to seek planning permission when changing the use of a property from the new Class C3 to C4 with effect from today. We will lose the control of insisting on conditions where consent might have been granted and it seems as if we will now have to rely on the possibility of an Article 4 Directive. This will be cumbersome and potentially expensive if compensation issues are not addressed and dealt with properly.

Whilst we understand and applaud the general thrust of the Government’s desire to remove layers of bureaucracy where HMO’s simply do not present a problem, what is required is a simple mechanism which will allow individual Councils where there is a demonstrable issue of local concern to “opt-out” of the new regime, thereby maintaining our ability as part of the wider localism agenda to make local decisions that affect our residents locally.

That would certainly be the case here in Bournemouth and I would certainly welcome your urgent views on the matter.

Yours sincerely,

Cllr Peter Charon
Redhill and Northbourne Ward

Leader and Housing Portfolio Holder


Government statement on HMOs

Published 7 September 2010

Housing Minister Grant Shapps says that landlords and councils will no longer be faced with bureaucracy aimed at micro-managing rented housing.

The Minister laid new regulations that could cut as many as 8,500 planning applications from the system, freeing up councils to focus on local priorities. Currently landlords have to submit a planning application to rent their properties to unrelated tenants - known as Houses in Multiple Occupation. Regulations published today will ensure councils only have to use this power where they know high concentrations of shared homes are a problem.

Too many shared homes in one area can cause problems. A high number of short term tenants with little stake in the community can leave an area with an unloved look and feel, which can sometimes create seasonal ghost towns that harm local economies, anti-social behaviour and an increase in crime.

But the Minister said that a blanket requirement to manage these through the planning system is a drain on council resources, and threatens to drive good landlords away from the rental sector because of increased costs and red tape, therefore restricting availability of affordable homes for rent.

Currently up to 8,500 planning applications may be added to the system each year if every landlord looking to turn their property into a shared home is forced to submit an application, regardless of local circumstances.

Housing Minister Grant Shapps said:

"Councils understand their local area best, and they don't need burdensome rules that assume housing issues in every town, village and hamlet are exactly the same. I am also committed to safeguard the supply of rented housing - shared homes are vital for people who want to live and work in towns and cities, and are important to the economy.

"That's why I'm giving councils greater flexibility to manage shared homes in their local area. Where there are local issues with shared homes, councils will have all the tools they need to deal with the problem - but they will avoid getting bogged down in pointless applications, and landlords won't be put off renting shared homes where they are needed."


HMO application blocked

14 July 2010

The tenacity of a Winton Forum member has led to the Council refusing planning permission for a property in Frederica Road to be turned into a House of Multiple Occupation.

The Forum member brought the application to the attention of Wallisdown and Winton West Councillors Rod Cooper and Nicola Green.

The Proposal will not now go ahead because it was considered that the use of the dwelling house as a House of Multiple Occupation with six bedrooms would result in an over intensive residential use, which would be harmful to the character and appearance of the locality. Furthermore, intensive use and increased levels of activity would adversely impact on the residential amenity of the neighbouring properties".

Interestingly, the reasons for refusal would apply to most planning applications to convert a residential house to HMOs. So let's get objecting!!!

Interestingly the property is still being advertised as 'To Let'. The landlord's presumption of obtaining planning permission is typical of how things have been up until now. The Planning Enforcement Officer has been made aware of this.

 

Another application ditched

7 August 2010

Winton residents have had yet another success - this time in Stanfield Road.

An application to convert 17 Stanfield Road into an HMO was turned down. The owner wanted to let it out to six students.

(Application Number 7-2010-24477).


Tips when objecting to an HMO application

The key areas when objecting to a HMO application are:

  • amenity
  • parking
  • refuse collection
  • litter
  • rubbish
  • overgrown gardens
  • overcrowding
  • change of area character
  • noise
  • reduction of available housing stock for local people
  • nuisance and saturation.

Records of complaints to the Police and Town Hall Environment agencies regarding problems with existing neighbouring HMOs are extremely useful.


Useful web sites

PPS 3 National policy. Difficult to read but has useful sections on criminality and ecology and as well as other policies restated in the local planning documents.

Government Planning Policy

Local Planning sites

Local Plan; although it is out of date it is still referred to and helpful

Useful for ideas of other current planning applications

Bournemouth Planning Board

Main page for the design guide. Current local policy. Very useful. Go through with a fine tooth comb!

Planning Aid; a free service giving advice to applicants and objectors

http://www.planning-applications.co.uk/objection.htm

http://www.bvps.org.uk/Objecting.htm

Another guide to objecting

Friends of the Earth - planning

http://www.planning-objections.com/

Communities Planning page

Bournemouth Civic Society -Planning

CPRE - Planning Help


The Housing Problem

In Winton, 12.89% of all housing is let as Houses of Multiple Occupancy (HMOs) to Bournemouth University and Arts Institute Students. Students make up over 25% of Winton's population! Most Students are well behaved and considerate neighbours but a small percentage are not and living near them is a nightmare for many of members of our community. Winton has reached and passed HMO saturation point. Efforts to police anti social behaviour, although well meant, have been ineffective and for many members of our community their life is a misery. Some streets in Winton are over 50% HMOs.

Recent legislation will provide your council with the opportunity to redress the balance between the Student population and the rest of the Winton Community. The Council now has the power to control the number of HMOs in your street and in your area.

Your Council has started a public consultation for a Local Development Framework Core Strategy. Included in this consultation will be the opportunity to look at Sustainable Communities. Many of you believe Winton is no longer a sustainable community and residents are selling up and leaving the area.

The University year ends this month and many of Winton's students will return to their home towns. Alarmingly there has been recent activity with even more properties being purchased by would be HMO landlords. What can you do about this?

If you agree that Winton has reached saturation point and the level of Student HMOs must be rolled-back then contact your Councillor:

anniina.davie@bournemouth.gov.uk (07711 502 204)

johann.edward@bournemouth.gov.uk (01202 243598)

theo.stratton@bournemouth.gov.uk (07746 427308)

And Member of Parliament

Conor Burns MP conor.burns.mp@parliament.uk (01202 776607)

If you live in Charminster/Queen's Park, your councillors are:

carol.ainge@bournemouth.gov.uk (01202 395110)

mark.anderson@bournemouth.gov.uk (01202 775483 )

Cheryl Johnson cherylaj@msn.com (07789 711524)

and Member of Parliament

Tobias Elwood ellwoodt@parliament.uk (01202) 397047)

Let them know exactly how you feel. It's your community - don't let apathy deprive you of it.